We combine earthquake spectra from multiple studies to investigate whether the increase in stress drop with depth often observed in the crust is real, or an artifact of decreasing attenuation (increasing Q) with depth. In many studies, empirical path and attenuation corrections are assumed to be independent of the earthquake source depth. We test this assumption by investigating whether a realistic increase in Q with depth (as is widely observed) could remove some of the observed apparent increase in stress drop with depth. We combine event spectra, previously obtained using spectral decomposition methods, for over 50,000 earthquakes (M0 to M5) from 12 studies in California, Nevada, Kansas and Oklahoma. We find that the relative high-frequency content of the spectra systematically increases with increasing earthquake depth, at all magnitudes. By analyzing spectral ratios between large and small events as a function of source depth, we explore the relative importance of source and attenuation contributions to this observed depth dependence. Without any correction for depth-dependent attenuation, we find a systematic increase in stress drop, rupture velocity, or both, with depth, as previously observed. When we add an empirical, depth-dependent attenuation correction, the depth dependence of stress drop systematically decreases, often becoming negligible. The largest corrections are observed in regions with the largest seismic velocity increase with depth. We conclude that source parameter analyses, whether in the frequency or time domains, should not assume path terms are independent of source depth, and should more explicitly consider the effects of depth-dependent attenuation.

Jiewen Zhang

and 2 more

Earthquake stress drop is an important source parameter that directly links to strong ground motion and fundamental questions in earthquake physics. Stress drop estimations may contain significant uncertainties due to factors such as variations in material properties and data limitations, which limits the applications of stress drop interpretations. Using a high-resolution borehole network, we analyze 4537 earthquakes in the Parkfield area in Northern California between 2001 and 2016 with spectral decomposition and an improved stacking method. To evaluate the influence of spatiotemporal variations of material properties on stress drop estimations, we apply six different strategies to account for spatial variations of velocity and attenuation changes, and divide earthquakes into three separate time periods to correct temporal variations of attenuation. These results show that appropriate corrections can significantly reduce the scatter in stress drop estimations, and decrease apparent depth and magnitude dependence. We further investigate the influence of data limitations on stress drop estimations, and show that insufficient bandwidth may cause systematic underestimation and increased stress drop scatter. The stress drop measurements from the high-frequency borehole recordings exhibit complex stable spatial patterns with no clear correlation with the nature of fault slip, or the slip distribution of the 2004 M6 earthquake. In some regions with the largest numbers of earthquakes, we can resolve temporal variations that indicate stress drop decrease following the 2004 earthquake, and gradual recovery. These temporal variations do not affect the long-term stress drop spatial variations, suggesting local material properties may control the spatial heterogeneity of stress drop.

Xiaowei Chen

and 1 more

Earthquake stress drop is an important source parameter that directly links to strong ground motion. However, estimating stress drops is often challenging due to many factors, such as data limitations, methodology, and attenuation. Different studies may yield highly inconsistent stress drop values for the same earthquakes, leading to different interpretations of stress drop scaling and spatial patterns. Stress drop is also important for interpretation of earthquake triggering processes. In particular, the roles of foreshocks have continuous debate, and some recent studies show that detailed source parameter analysis is the key. In this study, we combine analyses of three sequences in Southern California using different methods to investigate the resolution of stress drops and the roles of foreshocks. The three sequences include the M7 El-Mayor Cucapah, the 2012 M5 Brawley swarm, and the 2019 M7 Ridgecrest sequence. The Ridgecrest sequence will participate in the Community Stress Drop Validation Study. For each sequence, we apply an improved stacking method and a spectral ratio method. We will use different types of waves: P-wave, S-wave, and Coda-wave. Stress drop results from this study will be compared with available previous studies. We will first discuss the influence of wave type and methodology on stress drop estimations, then we will investigate detailed stress interactions between foreshocks and the mainshock for different types of earthquake sequences (i.e., mainshock-aftershock and swarms that involve aseismic slip or fluid).