loading page

Verified hypotheses on the ‘nurse’ and ‘burial’ effects on introduced Quercus rubra regeneration in the European Scots pine forest
  • +1
  • Beata Woziwoda,
  • Marcin Dyderski,
  • Anastazja Gręda,
  • Lee Frelich
Beata Woziwoda
University of Lodz Faculty of Biology and Environmental Protection

Corresponding Author:[email protected]

Author Profile
Marcin Dyderski
Polish Academy of Sciences Institute of Dendrology Kornik
Author Profile
Anastazja Gręda
University of Lodz Faculty of Biology and Environmental Protection
Author Profile
Lee Frelich
University of Minnesota
Author Profile


1. Recognition of favourable environmental conditions for seed germination and seedling survival in different types of forest sites is crucial both for effective regeneration of introduced tree and for control of its spontaneous spread. Studies on the encroachment of North American northern red oak Quercus rubra into European Scots pine forests revealed high abundances of seedlings and saplings under shrubs, with lower abundances in open areas or in clumps of bilberry Vaccinium myrtillus. It was unclear, does burying acorns by seed-hoarders in moss or soil in different microhabitats impact survival of red oak seeds and seedlings, and does acorn size matter? 2. Results of previous (observational) studies were verified in a 3-year experimental study: a pool of 900 sown acorns was monitored in natural conditions. 3. Study revealed that ~80% of sown acorns were lost due to pilferage, lack of germination, fungal infection, and death of sprouting acorns and leafed-out seedlings. The fate of acorns and seedlings depended largely on acorn size and differed among microsite types. Viable seedlings were twice as likely to develop from large- and medium-sized, than from small acorns. Surviving seedlings grew mainly from acorns sown under moss cover within bilberry clumps or in open area, confirming a positive ‘burial effect’. Less than 10% of acorns sown under shrubs developed into viable seedlings, contradicting former conclusions on their ‘nurse effect’. 4. The occurrence of extensive bilberry clumps and small clusters of shrubs in pine forests favours Q. rubra regeneration, but severe fluctuations of the warming climate limit the viability of red oak seeds and seedlings. Prognosed range shifts of native tree species and expected dramatic loss of V. myrtillus climatic optima will impact Q. rubra distribution in European forests. Meanwhile, to prevent red oak spread (if necessary), it is recommended to remove shrubs from pine stand.
21 Nov 2023Submitted to Ecology and Evolution
12 Feb 2024Assigned to Editor
12 Feb 2024Submission Checks Completed
04 Mar 20242nd Revision Received
06 Mar 2024Review(s) Completed, Editorial Evaluation Pending
12 Mar 2024Editorial Decision: Accept