To the editor:
We report a case of an adolescent
with relapsed metastatic yolk sac tumour (YST) of the pineal region who
received multimodal treatment and remains alive and progression-free at
5 years from his last end of treatment. This encouraging case
contributes to the limited existing body of literature on the management
of relapsed non-germinomatous germ cell tumours of the central nervous
system (CNS NG-GCT).
A 12-year-old male presented with a 2-week history of headache, nausea,
vomiting, ataxia and drowsiness. Head CT scan showed a pineal lesion,
subsequently confirmed on Magnetic Resonance (MR) (Supplemental figure
S1). No leptomeningeal spread on MRI. Serum alpha-fetoprotein (AFP)
1,832 ng/ml. Serum beta-human chorionic gonadotropin (β-HCG) 16 IU/L.
Cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) cytology: no malignant cells. AFP in CSF 34.9
ng/ml (β-HCG not available).
An endoscopic third ventriculostomy, stereotactic biopsy of the pineal
lesion, and insertion of a Rickham reservoir were undertaken. The
initial biopsy was inconclusive. A second biopsy was consistent with a
malignant GCT with predominant features of YST.
The child was treated as per SIOP CNS GCT 96 protocol off-trial with 4
cycles of cisplatin, etoposide and ifosfamide (PEI) with partial
response according to Response Evaluation Criteria in Solid Tumors
v1.11. Serum tumour markers normalized. Subsequently,
he received radical volumetric modulated arc therapy (VMAT) to the
residual tumour (54 Gy in 30 fractions). End of treatment MR scan
revealed a stable subcentimetre tumour residuum with negative serum
tumour markers.
Two years after the end of treatment, routine serum tumour markers
showed AFP 56.6 ng/ml and β-HCG <2 IU/L. MR brain and spine
demonstrated stable intracranial appearances, with a new solitary plaque
of enhancing tissue over the surface of the spinal cord posteriorly at
the level of T10 disc space (Supplemental figure S1). The child received
alternating carboplatin/etoposide and ifosfamide/etoposide for a total
of 4 cycles as per SIOP CNS GCT II trial (NCT01424839). After 4 cycles
of chemotherapy, the T10 meningeal spinal metastasis shrunk and serum
AFP decreased to 4.8 ng/ml. He then received high dose thiotepa and
etoposide followed by autologous stem cell transplant (ASCT) followed by
craniospinal irradiation -CSI- (30 Gy in 16 fractions) with a boost to
the spinal recurrence (20.8 Gy in 13 fractions). The end of treatment
MRI showed ongoing response and serum AFP was normal. This young man is
currently alive, with normal serum tumour markers and free of recurrence
5 years after treatment.
Whilst most relapsed CNS germinomas can be salvaged, relapsed CNS
NG-GCTs have a much worse prognosis2–4. There is no
international consensus on salvage therapy for relapsed CNS NG-GCT and
there are relatively few published case series with limited and
heterogeneous cases5. Murray et al.6reported a cohort of 32 relapsed CNS NG-GCT patients with a 5-year
overall survival (OS) of 9% (95%CI: 2-26). Of the 16 patients who
received high dose chemotherapy (HDC) and ASCT, 2 of 3 long term
survivors had received irradiation after HDC and ASCT. Similarly, Callec
et al.5 reported a retrospective multicenter study of
25 patients with relapsed CNS NG-GCT showing a 5-year OS of 72%
(95%CI: 46-87) for patients who received HDC versus 29% (95%CI: 4-61)
for those who didn’t (p=0.006). These studies and others have led the
Third International CNS Germ Cell Tumor Symposium to recommend HDC,
surgery, and irradiation, if feasible, for the management of relapsed
CNS NG-GCTs7.
Elevated serum AFP at initial diagnosis (>1000 ng/ml) was
incorporated as a poor prognostic factor in the SIOP CNS GCT II trial
(NCT01424839), following results of the SIOP CNS GCT
968. This case could receive CSI because he had only
had focal radiotherapy at initial diagnosis. However, cases with
metastatic disease at initial diagnosis who receive CSI upfront would
not have this choice in case of metastatic relapse. Although relapsed
CNS NG-GCTs have a dismal prognosis, this case illustrates the
importance of close surveillance with tumour markers and that long-term
survival is achievable with multimodal treatment, including induction
chemotherapy, high dose chemotherapy with ASCT, and radiotherapy.