Why are preprints important to scientific progress?

The current model of scientific publishing very much relies on the original model put forward by The Royal Society in 1665. This model aimed to ensure that only the most robust scientific discoveries were published by engaging the scientific community in peer reviews of other’s work, and provide priority of discovery based on the publication date. Whilst it made sense at the time it was created, scientific communication based on these simple rules needs to be innovated to match current technological advancement and ensure a faster and more equitable access to information. Furthermore, the current publishing system has created a culture where scientific success is primarily judged on the number of publications in high impact journals, rather than on the contribution that the research has made to the scientific community, and the world at large. This pressure to publish in high impact journals has resulted in the steady increase in the number of experiments required for publication and correlated increased in time to first first-author publication for PhD students \cite{Vale_2015}.
Preprints hold the promise of bringing research back to the reason we all practice science: to test hypotheses and generate new knowledge that will help us tackle many of the scientific challenges in the world. Posting research output in an open repository helps to dissociate the research from the career reward system and flips the focus to science first, then publication later. The hope is that this will enable researchers to focus on producing robust data, without feeling pressured to align their research with the interests of a few select journals. In addition, preprints provide an opportunity for authors to gain useful feedback on their work prior to publication, and to also gain control over when their results are seen by the scientific community.

Why incorporate preprints into journal club discussions and why write a review/send comments to authors?

In order for preprints to be embraced by all scientists, the incentives to submit preprints need to be well established. This includes funding agencies encouraging/enforcing these practices, and Institutions accepting preprints as evidence of research success during hiring and tenure track evaluations. Whilst these policy changes are beginning to occur, we believe the incorporation of preprints into journal club practices, and the writing of preprint reviews, will provide an additional incentive for submitting preprints, both for the preprint JC host (in terms of training in review writing) and the preprint authors (from the insight and feedback gained from the preprint JC review). In addition, by sending preprint reviews directly to the preprint corresponding author, preprint JC hosts can expand their network in their field of research, which may have a positive impact on their career. Although some early career researchers may feel concerned about sending/posting critical reviews of authors that are influential in their field, there are platforms that will allow the reviewer’s identity to be hidden from the author, e.g. Academic Karma. Here at PREreview, we hope to encourage the open commenting on preprints by creating a welcoming and supportive community backed by a supportive Code of Conduct
Although incorporation of preprints into journal club practices should be a relatively simple process, we understand that there are many scientists that are unaware of preprints, some that are resistant to them, and also there is often little training available for early career researchers in the art of writing a manuscript review. Therefore, as early-mid career scientists, we want to tackle this by generating some resources to help encourage the incorporation of preprints into journal clubs, or to help initiate a preprint JC from scratch. We hope you will find the resources useful, and please let us know what you think by emailing us at contact@prereview.org.

Where can I find preprints?

You can search for preprints using Google Scholar, PrePubMed, or at several field-specific preprints repositories.

Where can I find more information?

If you would like to find out more, go to the ASAPbio website where there is a wealth of information about the history of preprints, summaries of the ASAPbio meetings, and ways to get involved. On that note, if you are interested in becoming an ASAPbio Ambassador and joining a welcoming and passionate community of open science enthusiasts, visit the ASAPbio Ambassadors page and sign up. You will receive a welcoming email and an invite to the ASAPbio Ambassador's Slack Team. You can also email us at contact@prereview.org and we can invite you to the Slack Team and answer any questions you may have about preprints and preprintJCs. We look forward to welcoming you to the community!